Where will FirstNet be next 9/11?

Thus far, only Rivada Networks has provided unequivocal interest in bidding on the FirstNet proposal, but many industry sources have expressed concern that the company could follow in the Frontline Wireless footsteps and pull out at the last minute. Meanwhile, there are lots of rumblings that many potential non-carrier entities—notably, large system integrators—are frustrated by the FirstNet proposal, because they are not sure how to monetize the spectrum asset to make the economics of the deal work.

While these and other valid concerns exist, the claims of those who say that no one will bid seem puzzling at this point, because so many key issues—for example, network users, cybersecurity approaches, legal liabilities, performance metrics and priority/preemption procedures—have not been determined yet. Until decisions are made in these and other key areas, it would seem to be impossible for any potential bidder to completely dismiss—or embrace—a multibillion-dollar opportunity like FirstNet.

More likely, any supposedly definitive positions from potential bidders are based on suspected scenarios, not actual facts. In addition, there probably is—or will be—a significant amount of posturing on the part of potential bidders. As is the case with quotes from general managers of NFL or NBA teams during the weeks leading up to their respective drafts, any statements from companies about FirstNet right now should be taken with a grain of salt.

However, if the result of this RFP is that no bidding groups choose to take on the FirstNet opportunity, it is important that policymakers focus their efforts and dialogue on how to improve a FirstNet deal to make it workable. Fingerpointing will be tempting—even understandable for a short time—but trying to place blame will not alter the basic facts of the situation.

This 700 MHz broadband spectrum is too valuable to lie fallow. First responders need this network. The public will be safer, if first responders have this network. In short, this issue is simply too important to let it become a political football for candidates to kick around during an election year.