https://urgentcomm.com/wp-content/themes/ucm_child/assets/images/logo/footer-new-logo.png
  • Home
  • News
  • Multimedia
    • Back
    • Multimedia
    • Video
    • Podcasts
    • Galleries
    • IWCE’s Video Showcase
    • Product Guides
  • Commentary
    • Back
    • Commentary
    • Urgent Matters
    • View From The Top
    • All Things IWCE
    • Legal Matters
  • Resources
    • Back
    • Resources
    • Webinars
    • White Papers
    • Reprints & Reuse
  • IWCE
    • Back
    • IWCE
    • Conference
    • Special Events
    • Exhibitor Listings
    • Premier Partners
    • Floor Plan
    • Exhibiting Information
    • Register for IWCE
  • About Us
    • Back
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Cookie Policy
  • Related Sites
    • Back
    • American City & County
    • IWCE
    • Light Reading
    • IOT World Today
    • Mission Critical Technologies
    • TU-Auto
  • In the field
    • Back
    • In the field
    • Broadband Push-to-X
    • Internet of Things
    • Project 25
    • Public-Safety Broadband/FirstNet
    • Virtual/Augmented Reality
    • Land Mobile Radio
    • Long Term Evolution (LTE)
    • Applications
    • Drones/Robots
    • IoT/Smart X
    • Software
    • Subscriber Devices
    • Video
  • Call Center/Command
    • Back
    • Call Center/Command
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • NG911
    • Alerting Systems
    • Analytics
    • Dispatch/Call-taking
    • Incident Command/Situational Awareness
    • Tracking, Monitoring & Control
  • Network Tech
    • Back
    • Network Tech
    • Interoperability
    • LMR 100
    • LMR 200
    • Backhaul
    • Deployables
    • Power
    • Tower & Site
    • Wireless Networks
    • Coverage/Interference
    • Security
    • System Design
    • System Installation
    • System Operation
    • Test & Measurement
  • Operations
    • Back
    • Operations
    • Critical Infrastructure
    • Enterprise
    • Federal Government/Military
    • Public Safety
    • State & Local Government
    • Training
  • Regulations
    • Back
    • Regulations
    • Narrowbanding
    • T-Band
    • Rebanding
    • TV White Spaces
    • None
    • Funding
    • Policy
    • Regional Coordination
    • Standards
  • Organizations
    • Back
    • Organizations
    • AASHTO
    • APCO
    • DHS
    • DMR Association
    • ETA
    • EWA
    • FCC
    • IWCE
    • NASEMSO
    • NATE
    • NXDN Forum
    • NENA
    • NIST/PSCR
    • NPSTC
    • NTIA/FirstNet
    • P25 TIG
    • TETRA + CCA
    • UTC
Urgent Communications
  • NEWSLETTER
  • Home
  • News
  • Multimedia
    • Back
    • Video
    • Podcasts
    • Omdia Crit Comms Circle Podcast
    • Galleries
    • IWCE’s Video Showcase
    • Product Guides
  • Commentary
    • Back
    • All Things IWCE
    • Urgent Matters
    • View From The Top
    • Legal Matters
  • Resources
    • Back
    • Webinars
    • White Papers
    • Reprints & Reuse
    • UC eZines
    • Sponsored content
  • IWCE
    • Back
    • Conference
    • Why Attend
    • Exhibitor Listing
    • Floor Plan
    • Exhibiting Information
    • Join the Event Mailing List
  • About Us
    • Back
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
    • Cookie Policy
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
  • Related Sites
    • Back
    • American City & County
    • IWCE
    • Light Reading
    • IOT World Today
    • TU-Auto
  • newsletter
  • In the field
    • Back
    • Internet of Things
    • Broadband Push-to-X
    • Project 25
    • Public-Safety Broadband/FirstNet
    • Virtual/Augmented Reality
    • Land Mobile Radio
    • Long Term Evolution (LTE)
    • Applications
    • Drones/Robots
    • IoT/Smart X
    • Software
    • Subscriber Devices
    • Video
  • Call Center/Command
    • Back
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • NG911
    • Alerting Systems
    • Analytics
    • Dispatch/Call-taking
    • Incident Command/Situational Awareness
    • Tracking, Monitoring & Control
  • Network Tech
    • Back
    • Cybersecurity
    • Interoperability
    • LMR 100
    • LMR 200
    • Backhaul
    • Deployables
    • Power
    • Tower & Site
    • Wireless Networks
    • Coverage/Interference
    • Security
    • System Design
    • System Installation
    • System Operation
    • Test & Measurement
  • Operations
    • Back
    • Critical Infrastructure
    • Enterprise
    • Federal Government/Military
    • Public Safety
    • State & Local Government
    • Training
  • Regulations
    • Back
    • Narrowbanding
    • T-Band
    • Rebanding
    • TV White Spaces
    • None
    • Funding
    • Policy
    • Regional Coordination
    • Standards
  • Organizations
    • Back
    • AASHTO
    • APCO
    • DHS
    • DMR Association
    • ETA
    • EWA
    • FCC
    • IWCE
    • NASEMSO
    • NATE
    • NXDN Forum
    • NENA
    • NIST/PSCR
    • NPSTC
    • NTIA/FirstNet
    • P25 TIG
    • TETRA + CCA
    • UTC
acc.com

Land Mobile Radio


News

Judge sides with Motorola Solutions, denies Hytera request for retrial, reduced damages

Judge sides with Motorola Solutions, denies Hytera request for retrial, reduced damages

  • Written by Donny Jackson
  • 21st October 2020

A federal-court judge this week released an order denying Hytera’s requests for a retrial or a reduction in the $764.6 million in damages for utilizing Motorola Solutions trade secrets and copyrighted software code to develop much of its DMR product portfolio.

“Hytera has not met the high standard for judgment as a matter of law, or for a new trial, or for reconsideration of previous orders or remittitur,” Judge Charles Norgle wrote in the order.

“The jury and the court were not biased, the procedures in this case were proper, the legal decisions were correct, the legal elements of Motorola’s claims were met, and the jury returned a verdict and award that are proper under the law and supported by overwhelming evidence that was submitted at trial—evidence, the court notes, which was robustly and meticulously challenged by skilled counsel for Hytera at each and every turn.”

Norgle’s ruling noted that he rejects “each and every argument raised by Hytera in its … motion and denies the motion in its entirety, except as to the issue of the advisory jury verdict on the equitable issues.” On these equitable issues, Norgle ordered both sides to submit proposed findings of fact on the matter.

Norgle’s order reaffirms the judgment he entered in March against Hytera—a decision that upheld the unanimous jury verdict issued in February that awarded Motorola Solutions all damages that it sought in the case, which was argued over a four-month period. The massive damages award forced Hytera’s U.S. divisions to seek Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in May.

Motorola Solutions applauded the Norgle order in a statement provided to IWCE’s Urgent Communications.

“Motorola Solutions is pleased by Judge Norgle’s decision to reject Hytera’s motion for a new trial, upholding the jury’s verdict that Hytera misappropriated Motorola’s trade secrets and infringed Motorola’s copyrights, as well as the jury’s award of over $764.5 million to Motorola,” according to the Motorola Solutions statement.

“Motorola Solutions is proud to be a pioneering technology and innovation leader, and we remain committed to vigorously pursuing our patent infringement, copyright infringement and trade-secret-theft lawsuits against Hytera.”

Hytera expressed a different sentiment about the ruling in its statement to IWCE’s Urgent Communications.

“Hytera is very disappointed by the district court’s refusal to reduce the damages awarded or, at a minimum, to order a new trial,” according to the Hytera statement. “Hytera will appeal this ruling and any other adverse decisions on the motions still pending before the district court to the United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit.

“During this legal process, Hytera will continue to provide the same outstanding support it always has to both its dealers and customers.”

This order does not address Motorola Solutions’ request for injunctive relief that would prohibit Hytera from selling key offerings in its portfolio of DMR offerings. Motorola Solutions attorneys have asked Norgle for a worldwide permanent injunction, primarily because Hytera has continued to sell the contested DMR products since Norgle entered his judgment in March.

Norgle’s decision on the injunction has been anticipated throughout the LMR industry. If Motorola Solutions’ request for injunctive relief is granted, Hytera impact on the market would be greatly diminished, according to most sources. Without any kind of injunction, Hytera could continue to sell its DMR products as it has for years, albeit under a new entity within U.S. established during the Chapter 11 bankruptcy proceeding.

Of course, the driving factor in the need for Hytera’s U.S. divisions to declare bankruptcy is the $764.6 million in damages that Hytera owes Motorola Solutions as a result of the trade-secrets and copyright case.

Absent the massive federal-court award to Motorola Solutions, the Hytera U.S. divisions would remain viable businesses—a fact acknowledged in the Motorola Solution motion for dismissal. For the year ending on Dec. 31, 2019, the two primary Hytera U.S. divisions generated combined revenues of $42.9 million, although the net operating income resulted in a loss of about $100,000, according to the Huang declaration.

Hytera attorneys asked Norgle for a new trial in the matter, but the judge denied the request.

“Hytera raises three distinct arguments claiming it is entitled to judgment as a matter of law: 1. Motorola has failed to satisfy the elements of a trade-secret claim; 2. Motorola’s trade-secret claims are barred by the statute of limitations; and 3. Motorola has failed to state a copyright claim for several reasons,” Norgle states in his order.

“Hytera cannot overcome its high burden on any of these arguments, as the evidence supports the verdict. The court will not overturn the jury verdict unless no reasonable juror could have found in favor of Motorola, and Hytera cannot meet this burden, given the evidence presented in this case.”

During the federal-court trial that began last November, Hytera attorneys acknowledged that three former Motorola (the company had not yet changed its name to Motorola Solutions at the time) employees—Samuel Chia, Y.T. Kok and G.S. Kok—accessed more than 7,000 Motorola documents prior to each of them leaving and joining Hytera shortly in 2008. However, Hytera attorneys described the three engineers as “bad apples” who did not share with anyone else at Hytera that the DMR trade secrets and software were taken from Motorola.

In his order, Norgle notes evidence that G.S. Kok—the first of the three Motorola employees to be hired by Hytera—expressed surprise that Hytera had not been able to develop even a prototype DMR system on its own. At the request of Chia, Y.T. Kok—still working at Motorola at the time—began downloading technical documents that provided solutions to DMR problems identified by Hytera engineers, according to Norgle’s order.

In some cases, Hytera copied the Motorola software code entirely—“including, notably, code which contained identical misspellings at points,” Norgle notes in his order.

In other instances, Hytera officials attempted to hide the use of Motorola software code in its DMR products, according to Norgle.

“Hytera argues that the jury should not have been instructed on spoliation of evidence because the court did not make a finding that Hytera acted intentionally in bad faith in destroying evidence,” Norgle’s order states. “Evidence in the record supports such a bad-faith finding, however.

“In June 2008, for example, G.S. Kok wrote to Sam Chia that they ‘needed to re-write softwares to look different from Motorola’ in order to ‘protect the company from impending lawsuits. Huang and Chia deleted evidence of misappropriation to conceal their theft.”

Hytera attorneys have argued that the damages are unfair, because they are based on Hytera’s worldwide sales of DMR products. Given that the case is before a U.S. court, Hytera believes that any damages should be calculated based solely on U.S. sales.

But Norgle disagreed with this notion in his order, noting that “other courts have reviewed and agreed with this court’s reasoning or come to similar conclusions as to the reach of the DTSA [Defend Trade Secrets Act] and the ITSA [Illinois Trade Secrets Act].”

 

Tags: homepage-featured-4 Companies Critical Infrastructure Cybersecurity Enterprise Federal Government/Military Funding Land Mobile Radio News Policy Security Software Standards State & Local Government System Design System Operation Wireless Networks News

Most Recent


  • Public-safety coalition renews efforts to secure federal NG911 funding
    A coalition of public-safety associations today reiterated its support for federal legislation that would provide the funding needed to pay for 911 centers to migrate from legacy technologies to an IP-based next-generation 911 (NG911) platform that is designed to support multimedia communications, as well as traditional voice calls. Representatives of the Public Safety Next Generation […]
  • Judge sides with Motorola Solutions, denies Hytera request for retrial, reduced damages
    Newscan: Cyberattacks on DoE national labs draw lawmaker scrutiny
    Web Roundup Items from other news organizations Cyberattacks on DoE national labs draw lawmaker scrutiny Blinken postpones trip to Beijing after Chinese spy balloon spotted over U.S., officials say To protect satellites, secure your networks, chief of space ops says Ransomware offlines Arizona’s largest school district Mending the fabric: FCC says to file broadband-location challenges […]
  • The shine begins to wear off 5G private wireless
    Verizon had high hopes for private wireless networking. The company had predicted that by now it would be well on its way to making billions of dollars from the sale of custom 4G and 5G networks dedicated exclusively to its enterprise customers. Indeed, during 2021 Verizon execs pegged the total addressable market for private wireless at around […]
  • Phishers trick Microsoft into granting them 'verified' Cloud Partner status
    Late last year, a group of threat actors managed to obtain “verified publisher” status through the Microsoft Cloud Partner Program (MCPP). This allowed them to surpass levels of brand impersonation ordinarily seen in phishing campaigns, as they distributed malicious applications bolstered by a verified blue badge only ever given to trusted vendors and service providers in […]

Leave a comment Cancel reply

To leave a comment login with your Urgent Comms account:

Log in with your Urgent Comms account

Or alternatively provide your name, email address below:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Content

  • Hytera sale of U.S. assets halted, federal court to hear Motorola Solutions injunction request
  • Hytera subsidiary increases bid to buy bankrupt U.S. divisions as Motorola Solutions seeks to block sale
  • Hytera America files Chapter 11 bankruptcy, citing Motorola Solutions litigation woes
  • Motorola Solutions logo
    Motorola Solutions awarded $764 million in trade-secret theft case against Hytera

Commentary


How 5G is making cities safer, smarter, and more efficient

26th January 2023

3GPP moves Release 18 freeze date to March 2024

18th January 2023

Do smart cities make safer cities?

  • 1
6th January 2023
view all

Events


UC Ezines


IWCE 2019 Wrap Up

13th May 2019
view all

Twitter


UrgentComm

Public-safety coalition renews efforts to secure federal NG911 funding dlvr.it/ShwGfn

4th February 2023
UrgentComm

Newscan: Cyberattacks on DoE national labs draw lawmaker scrutiny dlvr.it/Shvpw3

3rd February 2023
UrgentComm

The shine begins to wear off 5G private wireless dlvr.it/Shth0P

3rd February 2023
UrgentComm

Phishers trick Microsoft into granting them ‘verified’ Cloud Partner status dlvr.it/Shqngn

2nd February 2023
UrgentComm

Shapeshifting robot can morph from a liquid to a solid dlvr.it/Shqk9K

2nd February 2023
UrgentComm

Automakers against stampede to BEV dominance dlvr.it/ShpX08

2nd February 2023
UrgentComm

FCC nominee Gigi Sohn headed for third Senate hearing dlvr.it/ShpDcZ

1st February 2023
UrgentComm

Sign up to learn how to successfully manage your Motorola ASTRO® 25 System: spr.ly/60143j8fp https://t.co/XcxiUwzN27

1st February 2023

Newsletter

Sign up for UrgentComm’s newsletters to receive regular news and information updates about Communications and Technology.

Expert Commentary

Learn from experts about the latest technology in automation, machine-learning, big data and cybersecurity.

Business Media

Find the latest videos and media from the market leaders.

Media Kit and Advertising

Want to reach our digital and print audiences? Learn more here.

DISCOVER MORE FROM INFORMA TECH

  • American City & County
  • IWCE
  • Light Reading
  • IOT World Today
  • Mission Critical Technologies
  • TU-Auto

WORKING WITH US

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Events
  • Careers

FOLLOW Urgent Comms ON SOCIAL

  • Privacy
  • CCPA: “Do Not Sell My Data”
  • Cookie Policy
  • Terms
Copyright © 2023 Informa PLC. Informa PLC is registered in England and Wales with company number 8860726 whose registered and Head office is 5 Howick Place, London, SW1P 1WG.