https://urgentcomm.com/wp-content/themes/ucm_child/assets/images/logo/footer-logo.png
  • Home
  • News
  • Multimedia
    • Back
    • Multimedia
    • Video
    • Podcasts
    • Galleries
  • Commentary
    • Back
    • Commentary
    • Urgent Matters
    • View From The Top
    • All Things IWCE
    • Legal Matters
  • Resources
    • Back
    • Resources
    • Events
    • Webinars
    • White Papers
    • Reprints & Reuse
  • IWCE
    • Back
    • IWCE
    • Conference
    • Special Events
    • Exhibitor Listings
    • Premier Partners
    • Floor Plan
    • Exhibiting Information
    • Register for IWCE
  • About Us
    • Back
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Cookies Policy
  • Related Sites
    • Back
    • American City & County
    • IWCE
    • Light Reading
    • IOT World Today
    • Mission Critical Technologies
    • Microwave/RF
    • T&D World
    • TU-Auto
  • In the field
    • Back
    • In the field
    • Broadband Push-to-X
    • Internet of Things
    • Project 25
    • Public-Safety Broadband/FirstNet
    • Virtual/Augmented Reality
    • Land Mobile Radio
    • Long Term Evolution (LTE)
    • Applications
    • Drones/Robots
    • IoT/Smart X
    • Software
    • Subscriber Devices
    • Video
  • Call Center/Command
    • Back
    • Call Center/Command
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • NG911
    • Alerting Systems
    • Analytics
    • Dispatch/Call-taking
    • Incident Command/Situational Awareness
    • Tracking, Monitoring & Control
  • Network Tech
    • Back
    • Network Tech
    • Interoperability
    • LMR 100
    • LMR 200
    • Backhaul
    • Deployables
    • Power
    • Tower & Site
    • Wireless Networks
    • Coverage/Interference
    • Security
    • System Design
    • System Installation
    • System Operation
    • Test & Measurement
  • Operations
    • Back
    • Operations
    • Critical Infrastructure
    • Enterprise
    • Federal Government/Military
    • Public Safety
    • State & Local Government
    • Training
  • Regulations
    • Back
    • Regulations
    • Narrowbanding
    • T-Band
    • Rebanding
    • TV White Spaces
    • None
    • Funding
    • Policy
    • Regional Coordination
    • Standards
  • Organizations
    • Back
    • Organizations
    • AASHTO
    • APCO
    • DHS
    • DMR Association
    • ETA
    • EWA
    • FCC
    • IWCE
    • NASEMSO
    • NATE
    • NXDN Forum
    • NENA
    • NIST/PSCR
    • NPSTC
    • NTIA/FirstNet
    • P25 TIG
    • TETRA + CCA
    • UTC
Urgent Communications
  • NEWSLETTER
  • Home
  • News
  • Multimedia
    • Back
    • Video
    • Podcasts
    • Galleries
  • Commentary
    • Back
    • All Things IWCE
    • Urgent Matters
    • View From The Top
    • Legal Matters
  • Resources
    • Back
    • Events
    • Webinars
    • White Papers
    • Reprints & Reuse
    • UC eZines
  • IWCE
    • Back
    • Conference
    • Special Events
    • Exhibitor Listings
    • Floor Plan
    • Exhibiting Information
    • Register for IWCE
  • About Us
    • Back
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Cookies Policy
  • Related Sites
    • Back
    • American City & County
    • IWCE
    • Light Reading
    • IOT World Today
    • Mission Critical Technologies
    • Microwave/RF
    • T&D World
    • TU-Auto
  • newsletter
  • In the field
    • Back
    • Internet of Things
    • Broadband Push-to-X
    • Project 25
    • Public-Safety Broadband/FirstNet
    • Virtual/Augmented Reality
    • Land Mobile Radio
    • Long Term Evolution (LTE)
    • Applications
    • Drones/Robots
    • IoT/Smart X
    • Software
    • Subscriber Devices
    • Video
  • Call Center/Command
    • Back
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • NG911
    • Alerting Systems
    • Analytics
    • Dispatch/Call-taking
    • Incident Command/Situational Awareness
    • Tracking, Monitoring & Control
  • Network Tech
    • Back
    • Cybersecurity
    • Interoperability
    • LMR 100
    • LMR 200
    • Backhaul
    • Deployables
    • Power
    • Tower & Site
    • Wireless Networks
    • Coverage/Interference
    • Security
    • System Design
    • System Installation
    • System Operation
    • Test & Measurement
  • Operations
    • Back
    • Critical Infrastructure
    • Enterprise
    • Federal Government/Military
    • Public Safety
    • State & Local Government
    • Training
  • Regulations
    • Back
    • Narrowbanding
    • T-Band
    • Rebanding
    • TV White Spaces
    • None
    • Funding
    • Policy
    • Regional Coordination
    • Standards
  • Organizations
    • Back
    • AASHTO
    • APCO
    • DHS
    • DMR Association
    • ETA
    • EWA
    • FCC
    • IWCE
    • NASEMSO
    • NATE
    • NXDN Forum
    • NENA
    • NIST/PSCR
    • NPSTC
    • NTIA/FirstNet
    • P25 TIG
    • TETRA + CCA
    • UTC
acc.com

Land Mobile Radio


News

Federal judge denies Motorola Solution injunction request, orders DMR royalty talks with Hytera

Federal judge denies Motorola Solution injunction request, orders DMR royalty talks with Hytera

  • Written by Donny Jackson
  • 19th December 2020

Hytera will be able to continue selling its portfolio of DMR products, but the China-based LMR manufacturer will have to pay Motorola Solutions a “reasonable royalty” for the right to use trade secrets that Hytera stole from Motorola more than a decade ago, according to a federal court ruling released today.

U.S. District Court Judge Charles Norgle denied Motorola Solutions’ request for a permanent injunction that would have blocked Hytera from selling much of its DMR offerings worldwide but indicated that Motorola Solutions should be compensated in the future in the form of a royalty amount that could be determined within weeks.

“The court finds that an injunction in this case would be inequitable and thus continues on to the alternative relief—a reasonable royalty,” Norgle states in his order. “Because the arguments in the pending briefing are undeveloped as to what a reasonable royalty in this case would be, the court will allow the highly competent counsel in this case to confer and propose a process as to determining this royalty.

“Hytera points out that the parties currently mediating this issue, and the court does not want to discourage an agreement among the parties. Thus, the parties shall submit a proposed plan no later than January 14, 2021. If no agreed plan can be reached, each party shall submit its own proposal.”

Hytera applauded the ruling, which most industry sources believe should allow the company to continue conducting its business with little or no significant negative impact on its existing customer base or dealer network.

“Hytera is very pleased with the recent ruling by the court, which officially denied [Motorola Solutions’] request for a permanent injunction,” according to the Hytera statement provided to IWCE’s Urgent Communications.

Motorola Solutions said it is “considering all options for further action” regarding its request for a permanent injunction in a statement provided to IWCE’s Urgent Communications. Otherwise, the intellectual-property lawsuit against Hytera has been a “clear victory” for Motorola Solutions, according to the statement.

“The jury in this case determined Hytera stole Motorola Solutions’ trade secrets and infringed our copyrights, and awarded $764.6 million in compensatory and exemplary damages to Motorola Solutions,” according to the Motorola Solutions’ statement. “Further, in October, the court denied Hytera’s motion for a new trial, noting that the February verdict was supported by ‘overwhelming evidence.’ This outcome is a clear repudiation of the illegal and anti-competitive tactics Hytera has employed for more than a decade.

“The Court’s decision today confirms that Hytera’s sale of products containing Motorola Solutions’ trade secrets continues to harm Motorola Solutions following the verdict, granting Motorola Solutions’ request for a royalty on every sale Hytera makes of the DMR products at issue going forward into the future. The Court will determine that additional royalty through subsequent briefing.”

Released online today, Norgle’s order was filed yesterday, according to an online federal-court database. However, none of the attorneys participating in a related Hytera bankruptcy hearing yesterday indicated any knowledge that an injunction decision from Norgle was imminent.

As a result, the California bankruptcy judge expressed support for the Chapter 11 sale of most Hytera’s U.S. assets to a new Hytera US entity and for the sale of the disputed DMR inventory—items that could have been subject to a Norgle injunction order—to be considered again during a Jan. 22 hearing.

Hytera America and Hytera Communications America (West) filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in May, in the wake of Norgle affirming a $764.6 million award against Hytera in March for utilize DMR trade secrets or copyrighted software stolen by former Motorola employees who left to work for Hytera in 2008. After the federal-court award was announced, Motorola Solutions asked Norgle for injunctive relief to block Hytera from selling many of its DMR products worldwide.

In his opinion, Norgle said that Motorola Solutions satisfied three of the four criteria he considered while making his assessment whether to grant a permanent injunction worldwide that would have prohibited the sale of many key Hytera DMR offerings.

Motorola Solutions attorneys were successful on the merits of the case, and Norgle said the arguments in the balance-of-hardship and public-interest tests “strongly favor” granting the Motorola Solutions injunction request. However, Motorola Solutions did not prove that it would suffer “irreparable harm” without an injunction, according to the federal-court judge.

“While the damages in this case are backward-looking only, and the injunction would prevent future harm, the nature of the harms suffered—and potentially to be suffered—by Motorola are compensable with damages,” Norgle states in his order. “In this respect, the words of another district court are persuasive, ‘This case is about money. No historic building is going to be destroyed. No toxins are going to be released into the environment. No ship is going to leave port, never to return.’

“While in some instances the theft of trade secrets no doubt could constitute irreparable harm, this is not the case … Given the testimony the court has heard about how the damages to Motorola can specifically be quantified and analyzed, the court cannot say that there is no adequate remedy at law for any market-share or price erosion.”

Although Norgle did not grant the requested injunctive relief, Motorola Solutions noted that the company is still awaiting for the judge to decide some aspects of the case that are extremely important to both Motorola Solutions and Hytera.

“The Court also notes that Motorola Solutions’ motion to force Hytera to immediately pay $764.6 million judgment, as well as Motorola Solutions’ motions for enhancement of that amount, are still under advisement,” according to the Motorola Solutions statement.

Norgle received the last briefs about the injunction request from the Hytera and Motorola Solutions attorneys weeks ago, but he did not issue an opinion until today. Motorola Solutions attorneys have argued that an worldwide injunction blocking the sale of many popular Hytera DMR offerings is needed, because Hytera has indicated that it will not pay the $764.6 million award and it continues to sell DMR products after the federal-court ruling.

Hytera attorneys have noted that the federal-court ruling does not limit Hytera’s ability to sell DMR products and that an injunction would be duplicative to the massive financial award already granted to Motorola Solution. In addition, Hytera filed briefs seeking a retrial and a reduction in the financial award granted by the federal court, but both requests have been denied.

Hytera previously has announced its intention to appeal the federal-court decision.

During the federal-court trial that began last November, Hytera attorneys acknowledged that three former Motorola (the company had not yet changed its name to Motorola Solutions at the time) employees—Samuel Chia, Y.T. Kok and G.S. Kok—accessed more than 7,000 Motorola documents prior to each of them leaving and joining Hytera shortly in 2008. However, Hytera attorneys described the three engineers as “bad apples” who did not share with anyone else at Hytera that the DMR trade secrets and software were taken from Motorola.

Hytera attorneys have argued that the award to Motorola should be reduced significantly, if the decision is not reversed. In contrast, Motorola Solutions asks that the financial award that China-based Hytera should pay should be increased by including the profits that Hytera has realized during the time since the trial started, interest and attorney fees.

Hytera also has argued that an injunction issued by a U.S. federal court only should apply within the U.S., which would mean Hytera could sell the DMR products in other countries. But Motorola Solutions asserts that language in the Defend Trade Secrets Act (DTSA) supports granting worldwide injunction in this case, because Hytera engaged in an “act in furtherance of the offense” in the U.S. through its participation in U.S. trade shows.

 

Tags: homepage-featured-4 Applications Companies Critical Infrastructure Enterprise Federal Government/Military Funding Land Mobile Radio News Policy Public Safety Software Standards State & Local Government Subscriber Devices System Design System Operation Wireless Networks News

Related


  • Motorola Solutions logo
    Federal judge to decide Hytera’s DMR future after Motorola Solutions files final injunction argument
    Motorola Solutions this week asked a federal judge to issue a global permanent injunction that would block most Hytera Communications’ sales of DMR products, claiming that China-based Hytera has “no intention” of paying a $764 million court-ordered award and continues to sell DMR offerings absent a court order. In the final brief submitted on the […]
  • Hytera opposes injunctive request, says Motorola Solutions ‘seeks to monopolize the market’
    Hytera Communications asked a federal judge to deny the Motorola Solutions request to block Hytera from selling the bulk of its DMR product portfolio, noting that a potential injunction would amount to “double recovery” on top of a $764.6 million jury verdict and would hand Motorola Solutions monopoly power that would harm consumers. “Motorola’s motivation […]
  • Hytera bankruptcy filings reveal plan to sell U.S. divisions, but Motorola Solutions asks court to block effort
    LMR manufacturer Hytera has asked a bankruptcy court’s permission to sell its U.S. business units in a Chapter 11 auction, but Motorola Solutions is trying to block the effort, claiming that the Hytera legal maneuver is simply an effort to avoid paying a $764.6 million federal-court award to Motorola Solution. These positions are evident in […]
  • $764.6 million judgment against Hytera made official, but Motorola Solutions injunction request still pending
    A federal judge on Friday entered a final judgment that Hytera Communications must pay Motorola Solutions $764.6 million without altering the jury’s verdict in the case, but all parties are awaiting the judge’s decision on injunctive efforts that would prevent Hytera from selling most of its DMR products. In his final judgment, Judge Charles Norgle […]

Leave a comment Cancel reply

To leave a comment login with your Urgent Comms account:

Log in with your Urgent Comms account

Or alternatively provide your name, email address below:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Content

  • At CES 2021, Verizon touts 5G connectivity as enabler in pandemic times
  • How the city of Fullerton navigated adding candidates to ballots remotely
  • Federal judge reduces Hytera legal payment to Motorola Solutions by $220.9 million
  • Florida county announces successful test of Motorola Solutions' cloud-based P25 core technology

Commentary


Public safety needs a better way to triage emergency calls

13th January 2021

In challenging year, working with public safety to move FirstNet forward

30th December 2020

Communications solutions must evolve quickly to meet needs of a changing world

31st October 2020
view all

Events


UC Ezines


IWCE 2019 Wrap Up

13th May 2019
view all

Twitter


UrgentComm

RT @IWCEexpo: 📆 Mark Your Calendars: IWCE will be returning to Las Vegas this September and registration is slated to open in April 📆 Wa…

15th January 2021
UrgentComm

RT @IWCEexpo: ⚡FLASH SALE: Don't miss this exclusive offer! Passes to #IBFVirtual are now 50% off with code TWITTER50. Take advantage of th…

6th November 2020
UrgentComm

Get ready for part 2 of "Ensuring Public Safety Emergency Communications" next week! @PCTEL_inc will explore… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

3rd November 2020
UrgentComm

Over the past few months, we’ve seen the world transform, and it's clear that cities will be affected in the long-t… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

27th October 2020
UrgentComm

Florida state & local agencies subscribing to the Statewide Law Enforcement Radio System (SLERS) will be able to co… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

26th October 2020
UrgentComm

Tune in to @slacorp CEO Josh Lober as he explains how the company has fully integrated its #PTT application to work… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

26th October 2020
UrgentComm

.@SierraWireless announced the commercial availability of the AirLink MG90 platform, which they tout as the first m… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

26th October 2020
UrgentComm

Attorneys for #Hytera and #MotorolaSolutions this week submitted final written arguments, apparently clearing a pat… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…

22nd October 2020

Newsletter

Sign up for UrgentComm’s newsletters to receive regular news and information updates about Communications and Technology.

Expert Commentary

Learn from experts about the latest technology in automation, machine-learning, big data and cybersecurity.

Business Media

Find the latest videos and media from the market leaders.

Media Kit and Advertising

Want to reach our digital and print audiences? Learn more here.

DISCOVER MORE FROM INFORMA TECH

  • American City & County
  • IWCE
  • Light Reading
  • IOT World Today
  • Mission Critical Technologies
  • Microwave/RF
  • T&D World
  • TU-Auto

WORKING WITH US

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Events
  • Careers

FOLLOW Urgent Comms ON SOCIAL

  • Privacy
  • CCPA: “Do Not Sell My Data”
  • Cookies Policy
  • Terms
Copyright © 2021 Informa PLC. Informa PLC is registered in England and Wales with company number 8860726 whose registered and Head office is 5 Howick Place, London, SW1P 1WG.
This website uses cookies, including third party ones, to allow for analysis of how people use our website in order to improve your experience and our services. By continuing to use our website, you agree to the use of such cookies. Click here for more information on our Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy.
X