https://urgentcomm.com/wp-content/themes/ucm_child/assets/images/logo/footer-new-logo.png
  • Home
  • News
  • Multimedia
    • Back
    • Multimedia
    • Video
    • Podcasts
    • Galleries
    • IWCE’s Video Showcase
    • IWCE 2022 Winter Showcase
    • IWCE 2023 Pre-event Guide
  • Commentary
    • Back
    • Commentary
    • Urgent Matters
    • View From The Top
    • All Things IWCE
    • Legal Matters
  • Resources
    • Back
    • Resources
    • Webinars
    • White Papers
    • Reprints & Reuse
  • IWCE
    • Back
    • IWCE
    • Conference
    • Special Events
    • Exhibitor Listings
    • Premier Partners
    • Floor Plan
    • Exhibiting Information
    • Register for IWCE
  • About Us
    • Back
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Cookie Policy
  • Related Sites
    • Back
    • American City & County
    • IWCE
    • Light Reading
    • IOT World Today
    • Mission Critical Technologies
    • TU-Auto
  • In the field
    • Back
    • In the field
    • Broadband Push-to-X
    • Internet of Things
    • Project 25
    • Public-Safety Broadband/FirstNet
    • Virtual/Augmented Reality
    • Land Mobile Radio
    • Long Term Evolution (LTE)
    • Applications
    • Drones/Robots
    • IoT/Smart X
    • Software
    • Subscriber Devices
    • Video
  • Call Center/Command
    • Back
    • Call Center/Command
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • NG911
    • Alerting Systems
    • Analytics
    • Dispatch/Call-taking
    • Incident Command/Situational Awareness
    • Tracking, Monitoring & Control
  • Network Tech
    • Back
    • Network Tech
    • Interoperability
    • LMR 100
    • LMR 200
    • Backhaul
    • Deployables
    • Power
    • Tower & Site
    • Wireless Networks
    • Coverage/Interference
    • Security
    • System Design
    • System Installation
    • System Operation
    • Test & Measurement
  • Operations
    • Back
    • Operations
    • Critical Infrastructure
    • Enterprise
    • Federal Government/Military
    • Public Safety
    • State & Local Government
    • Training
  • Regulations
    • Back
    • Regulations
    • Narrowbanding
    • T-Band
    • Rebanding
    • TV White Spaces
    • None
    • Funding
    • Policy
    • Regional Coordination
    • Standards
  • Organizations
    • Back
    • Organizations
    • AASHTO
    • APCO
    • DHS
    • DMR Association
    • ETA
    • EWA
    • FCC
    • IWCE
    • NASEMSO
    • NATE
    • NXDN Forum
    • NENA
    • NIST/PSCR
    • NPSTC
    • NTIA/FirstNet
    • P25 TIG
    • TETRA + CCA
    • UTC
Urgent Communications
  • NEWSLETTER
  • Home
  • News
  • Multimedia
    • Back
    • Video
    • Podcasts
    • Omdia Crit Comms Circle Podcast
    • Galleries
    • IWCE’s Video Showcase
    • IWCE 2023 Pre-event Guide
    • IWCE 2022 Winter Showcase
  • Commentary
    • Back
    • All Things IWCE
    • Urgent Matters
    • View From The Top
    • Legal Matters
  • Resources
    • Back
    • Webinars
    • White Papers
    • Reprints & Reuse
    • UC eZines
    • Sponsored content
  • IWCE
    • Back
    • Conference
    • Why Attend
    • Exhibitor Listing
    • Floor Plan
    • Exhibiting Information
    • Join the Event Mailing List
  • About Us
    • Back
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
    • Cookie Policy
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
  • Related Sites
    • Back
    • American City & County
    • IWCE
    • Light Reading
    • IOT World Today
    • TU-Auto
  • newsletter
  • In the field
    • Back
    • Internet of Things
    • Broadband Push-to-X
    • Project 25
    • Public-Safety Broadband/FirstNet
    • Virtual/Augmented Reality
    • Land Mobile Radio
    • Long Term Evolution (LTE)
    • Applications
    • Drones/Robots
    • IoT/Smart X
    • Software
    • Subscriber Devices
    • Video
  • Call Center/Command
    • Back
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • NG911
    • Alerting Systems
    • Analytics
    • Dispatch/Call-taking
    • Incident Command/Situational Awareness
    • Tracking, Monitoring & Control
  • Network Tech
    • Back
    • Cybersecurity
    • Interoperability
    • LMR 100
    • LMR 200
    • Backhaul
    • Deployables
    • Power
    • Tower & Site
    • Wireless Networks
    • Coverage/Interference
    • Security
    • System Design
    • System Installation
    • System Operation
    • Test & Measurement
  • Operations
    • Back
    • Critical Infrastructure
    • Enterprise
    • Federal Government/Military
    • Public Safety
    • State & Local Government
    • Training
  • Regulations
    • Back
    • Narrowbanding
    • T-Band
    • Rebanding
    • TV White Spaces
    • None
    • Funding
    • Policy
    • Regional Coordination
    • Standards
  • Organizations
    • Back
    • AASHTO
    • APCO
    • DHS
    • DMR Association
    • ETA
    • EWA
    • FCC
    • IWCE
    • NASEMSO
    • NATE
    • NXDN Forum
    • NENA
    • NIST/PSCR
    • NPSTC
    • NTIA/FirstNet
    • P25 TIG
    • TETRA + CCA
    • UTC
acc.com

Broadband Push-to-X


News

Final cases made about Airwave, ESN, before CMA issues provisional decision on Motorola Solutions

Final cases made about Airwave, ESN, before CMA issues provisional decision on Motorola Solutions

  • Written by Donny Jackson
  • 29th June 2022

Key players in the United Kingdom (UK) plans to deliver public-safety communications via the Airwave TETRA system or the much-delayed LTE-based Emergency Services Network (ESN) offered very different opinions on what should be done as UK competition watchdog prepares to make it provisional decision on the roles played by Motorola Solutions in both networks.

Yesterday, the Competition and Market Authority (CMA) posted on its website the last responses made by the UK Home Office, Motorola Solutions and EE—the wireless carrier charged with building the LTE network portion of the ESN—prior to the CMA issuing its “Provisional Decision” report. CMA is considering whether Motorola Solutions has too much market power and whether the company should have to divest Airwave or be subject to regulatory pricing to address cost and delivery concerns that the Home Office has cited about Airwave and the ESN.

CMA’s administrative timeline indicates that the provisional decision would be made by the end of June—tomorrow—but it is unclear when a report about the provisional decision will be made public. The responses posted yesterday on the CMA website were all submitted by the end of May.

In the latest submissions, there was little consensus among the parties about whether the CMA should take action against Motorola Solutions or what the potential remedies should be.

Motorola Solutions reiterated its argument that the CMA should not take any action, noting that it is meeting its contractual obligations for Airwave under terms agreed upon by the UK government, led by the Home Office. If the CMA does choose to alter the terms of the Airwave contract, the ruling could have a negative impact on the UK government’s relationship with all contractors, not just those associated with public safety, according to Motorola Solutions.

If the CMA decides to take action, it should not impact the current Airwave contract—a $2.09 billion, four-year deal with to extend the life of the Airwave system through the end of 2026—according to Motorola Solutions. Instead, any action should be applied to any negotiations/procurements that the UK government chooses to pursue if Airwave is needed in 2027 or beyond—a scenario that only would be needed if the ESN still was not ready to provide mission-critical voice communications to UK first responders by the end of 2026.

For the ESN to replace the Airwave TETRA network, the ESN needs to have mission-critical-push-to-talk (MCPTT) implemented as a mission-critical-voice alternative to the existing LMR system. The MCPTT offering is supposed to be supplied by Motorola Solutions—based on the PTT platform gained by purchasing Kodiak in 2017—but UK Home Office officials repeatedly have cited MCPTT issues as key reasons for the delay in ESN, which was supposed to be completed in 2019.

Many UK officials have expressed concern that Motorola Solutions is slowing the delivery of MCPTT to ensure that UK first responders remain dependent on Airwave—a much more lucrative contract for Motorola Solution than the ESN. Motorola Solutions repeatedly has denied this, noting that there are numerous other area besides MCPTT that have created ESN delays.

Whatever the reasons for the ESN delay, it has become a costly proposition for the UK government and its taxpayers. According to a filing by Home Office Secretary Matthew Rycroft that was updated last month, the total cost of the Airwave-to-ESN transition has risen by 6.2 billion pounds—about $7.6 billion, or more than the total cost of the much larger FirstNet system in the U.S.—since the project was procured in 2015.

In terms of potential solutions that the CMA could order, the UK Home Office submission expresses support for price controls.

“The Home Office considers that a charge control and associated transparency remedies are necessary,” according to one Home Office response. “Such remedies are necessary to address Airwave Solutions’ unilateral market power, although not necessarily the dual role that Motorola holds—albeit a reduction in Airwave’s price would, to an extent, marginally reduce but not remove, the incentives on Motorola to delay ESN.”

The Home Office also said that a CMA decision requiring Motorola Solutions to more transparent information would be helpful, but the benefits would be “marginal” if applied on a standalone basis, according to a Home Office submission that addresses potential remedies.

Potentially more beneficial would be a “structural separation” remedy, in which Motorola Solutions would be required to divest Airwave, although such an approach would need to be implemented carefully, according to the Home Office.

“Before imposing a structural separation remedy, requiring Motorola to divest Airwave Solutions, the Home Office would encourage the CMA to investigate and consider the potential risks that may arise as a result of such divestiture, in particular any risks that may erode or diminish the quality of service provided by the Airwave network,” the Home Office submission states.

“As the CMA will appreciate, a primary concern for the Home Office is to ensure the continuity of mobile radio communications for Great Britain’s emergency services and in turn their safety and the safety of the general public.”

Throughout all of the submissions, commercially sensitive phrases have been redacted—often at key junctures of the text—in the publicly available versions of the responses, including at this juncture of the Home Office document.

“Additionally, at this point in time, [redacted],” according to the Home Office submission. “Further, Motorola have warned [redacted], at least while there is a threat of divestiture. [Redacted]

“The Home Office is further concerned that, even if Motorola’s ability to delay ESN through its late delivery of Lot 2—and in particular the Kodiak MCPTT application—falls away, Motorola is still able to hamper the roll-out of ESN through other means. For example, amongst other things, the Home Office believes Motorola is [redacted].”

While Motorola Solutions is under contract to deliver the Lot 2 portion of the ESN—the part addressing software and services, including MCPTT—the LTE network for ESN largely is the responsibility of EE, a large commercial wireless carrier in the UK.

In its submission, EE also encourages the CMA to require Motorola Solutions to divest an asset, but the divestiture would be of its ESN role, not selling Airwave. EE’s submission also stresses the need for the CMA to require that Motorola Solutions provide an interworking solution that would support interoperability between Airwave users and ESN users during the critical transition period.

“Some form of ESN divestment remedy is necessary and … it should be designed in a way which provides for interworking and delivers ESN and the public interest benefits described above as soon and as effectively as possible,” the EE submission states. “Motorola itself suggests … that the proportionate response to address the Adverse Effect on Competition (AEC) arising from its dual role would be to require cessation of its participation in ESN.

“In EE’s view, this could resolve the AEC caused by Motorola’s dual role but other steps would also be necessary to facilitate the implementation of this divestment remedy for ESN.”

Part of EE’s recommended remedy would require Motorola Solutions provide the Kodiak source code to the ESN program, according to the EE submission.

“EE submits that deconflicted continued use of Kodiak can only be achieved by a remedy that the Kodiak Software source code be provided to the ESN Programme along with all appropriate documentation and knowledge transfer (with direct access to the relevant Kodiak specialists) on an expedited timeframe so that the Programme could then continue to develop a separate code branch to deliver the software required to make ESN successful,” the EE submission states.

EE’s submission also noted that Motorola Solutions provides software to control rooms—the UK equivalent of 911 centers in the U.S.—and that control-room software must be upgraded to work with MCPTT, whether it is from Motorola Solutions or another vendor.

“To ensure that there is no barrier to user organisations adopting ESN, we would invite the CMA to consider (and consult as appropriate with Emergency Services organisations) about the provision of control-room software and how its timely development can be guaranteed,” the EE submission states.

Not surprisingly, Motorola Solution disagreed with the notion of any suggested CMA remedies, noting that the UK government has agreed to all contractual term associated with Airwave—the UK’s nationwide TETRA system that Motorola Solutions bought in a deal that closed in early 2016.

Many UK officials have complained that Motorola Solutions is operating Airwave in an non-competitive environment. However, the notion that the UK government should have procured an LMR alternative when the ESN clearly would not be ready by the end of 2019 was not practical, according to the Motorola Solutions response addressing potential CMA remedies.

“Competition for the market as defined by the CMA took place with the Home Office’s decision to procure ESN, and Airwave simply provided the fallback solution to cover against the risk of delays,” according to the Motorola Solutions submission. “Although in theory that fallback service could have been procured, at this point, the thought experiment has lost all contact with reality.

“Given the high demands of running the Airwave service, no outside company would seek to come in and provide the highly demanding Airwave service—with all its legacy technology issues that would inevitably come out in due diligence—on a ‘pay as you go’ basis (bearing in mind that the Airwave network services can be [redacted]) without receiving a significant risk premium.

UK officials have complained repeatedly that Motorola Solutions will realize more than $1 billion in “excess profits” from contracts extending the use of Airwave beyond 2019, but Motorola Solutions’ internal-rate-of-return (IRR) figures are not out of line, according to the Motorola Solutions submission. In addition, Motorola Solutions claims it provided the Home Office with a less-expensive alternative in 2018, but that offer was declined.

“Neither of Motorola’s probability-weighted IRRs remotely justify intervention to rewrite the last years of a long-term contract,” the Motorola Solutions submission states.

“It would be biased, or at least give the appearance of bias, in the context of a market investigation to pretend that the Home Office had made an entirely different contractual choice six years ago, not least when the Home Office was specifically offered (in 2018) significant discounts in return for providing greater certainty to Airwave about the term over which services would be required.”

Motorola Solutions expressed its opposition to price controls and noted the potential broader implications that such action could have on the UK government’s procurement efforts in the future.

“Despite the protestations of the CMA, Motorola (and likely other prospective contractors) would regard the imposition of a charge control as a blatant attempt by the UK government to draw in regulatory powers to rewrite the terms of a contract to which it has agreed,” according to the Motorola Solutions submission. “This is deeply objectionable and—no matter what the CMA claims—will, in fact, severely undermine trust in the UK government as a contracting partner.”

Within the Motorola Solutions submission, the company reiterated its belief that the CMA provisional decision should not include any of the suggested remedies.

“Motorola strongly believes that, to the extent that any of the potential remedies appear in the provisional decision, this will simply be confirmation that:

  • the CMA has not conducted a fair and complete market investigation;
  • the CMA continues to rely on unsound economic analysis;
  • the CMA continues to ignore the actual operation of the market and decisions made by the Home Office, preferring instead to air vacuous theories about how competition within a contract might have worked; and
  • the market investigation has been aimed squarely at retrospectively re-writing the agreed terms of the Airwave contract for the benefit of the UK government.”

 

Tags: homepage-featured-4 Applications Broadband Push-to-X Companies Coverage/Interference Federal Government/Military Funding Interoperability Land Mobile Radio Long Term Evolution (LTE) News Policy Public Safety Public-Safety Broadband/FirstNet Regional Coordination Software Standards State & Local Government Subscriber Devices System Design System Installation System Operation Wireless Networks News

Most Recent


  • AT&T claims LTE coverage edge, FirstNet build more than 99% done
    AT&T claims a 250,000-square-mile coverage advantage and that the planned five-year deployment of the FirstNet public-safety broadband network operating on the 700 MHz Band 14 spectrum licensed to the FirstNet Authority is more than 99% complete as a contractual deadline approaches this week. AT&T—the contractor responsible for building and maintaining the FirstNet public-safety broadband system—made […]
  • Verizon
    Verizon Frontline supports U.S. Forest Service efforts against wildfires
    Verizon Frontline increased its support of entities responding to wildland fires during 2022, particularly the U.S. Forest Service (USFS), which accounted for more than half of this activity by the carrier’s Crisis Response Team, according to the carrier. Cory Davis, Verizon’s assistant vice president for public safety, said that Verizon Frontline provided communications support to […]
  • Autonomous-vehicle consequences could include more traffic
    Most discussions about driverless, autonomous cars, have led to claims that they will help reduce congestion. Not so, says the RAC Foundation. It cites a UK government report which believes the opposite is true. Claiming that driverless cars could increase congestion by 85% by 2060. Presently, it’s thought that drivers lose more than 80 hours […]
  • Tesla Model 3 hacked in less than 2 minutes at Pwn2Own contest
    Researchers from France-based pen-testing firm Synacktiv demonstrated two separate exploits against the Tesla Model 3 this week at the Pwn2Own hacking contest in Vancouver. The attacks gave them deep access into subsystems controlling the vehicle’s safety and other components. One of the exploits involved executing what is known as a time-of-check-to-time-of-use (TOCTTOU) attack on Tesla’s Gateway energy […]

One comment

  1. Avatar Highwalker 30th June 2022 @ 9:38 am
    Reply

    As I understand it, the end goal is to have the ESN as a 3GPP compliant MC system that any standards-compliant handset MCPTT client should be able to access, so whilst it may enable a short term fix/launch, I’m not clear why EE’s suggestion of making the Kodiak source code available to the ESN really speeds up getting to the end goal.

Leave a comment Cancel reply

To leave a comment login with your Urgent Comms account:

Log in with your Urgent Comms account

Or alternatively provide your name, email address below:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Content

  • UK Home Office plans to seek MCPTT option to Motorola Solutions for ESN, CMA says
  • UK Home Office outlines struggles with Motorola Solutions about Airwave, ESN
  • Motorola Solutions logo
    UK Home Office agrees to four-year Airwave extension worth $2.09 billion to Motorola Solutions
  • UK investigation of Motorola Solutions expected to yield preliminary results in April

Commentary


Updated: How ‘sidelink’ peer-to-peer communications can enhance public-safety operations

  • 1
27th February 2023

NG911 needed to secure our communities and nation

24th February 2023

How 5G is making cities safer, smarter, and more efficient

26th January 2023
view all

Events


UC Ezines


IWCE 2019 Wrap Up

13th May 2019
view all

Twitter


UrgentComm

Gallery: IWCE 2023 kicks off in Las Vegas dlvr.it/SlZlk4

28th March 2023
UrgentComm

AT&T claims LTE coverage edge, FirstNet build more than 99% done dlvr.it/SlXZfr

27th March 2023
UrgentComm

Verizon Frontline supports U.S. Forest Service efforts against wildfires dlvr.it/SlX1g3

27th March 2023
UrgentComm

Autonomous-vehicle consequences could include more traffic dlvr.it/SlWr67

27th March 2023
UrgentComm

Tesla Model 3 hacked in less than 2 minutes at Pwn2Own contest dlvr.it/SlVJg9

26th March 2023
UrgentComm

SES: JP Hemingway on satellites’ role in the digital divide, D2D and disasters dlvr.it/SlTL4h

25th March 2023
UrgentComm

House members introduce $15 billion NG911 funding bill dlvr.it/SlS0Lr

25th March 2023
UrgentComm

ADRF: Sun Kim discusses company’s new hybrid in-building wireless solution dlvr.it/SlRtSQ

25th March 2023

Newsletter

Sign up for UrgentComm’s newsletters to receive regular news and information updates about Communications and Technology.

Expert Commentary

Learn from experts about the latest technology in automation, machine-learning, big data and cybersecurity.

Business Media

Find the latest videos and media from the market leaders.

Media Kit and Advertising

Want to reach our digital and print audiences? Learn more here.

DISCOVER MORE FROM INFORMA TECH

  • American City & County
  • IWCE
  • Light Reading
  • IOT World Today
  • Mission Critical Technologies
  • TU-Auto

WORKING WITH US

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Events
  • Careers

FOLLOW Urgent Comms ON SOCIAL

  • Privacy
  • CCPA: “Do Not Sell My Data”
  • Cookie Policy
  • Terms
Copyright © 2023 Informa PLC. Informa PLC is registered in England and Wales with company number 8860726 whose registered and Head office is 5 Howick Place, London, SW1P 1WG.