https://urgentcomm.com/wp-content/themes/ucm_child/assets/images/logo/footer-new-logo.png
  • Home
  • News
  • Multimedia
    • Back
    • Multimedia
    • Video
    • Podcasts
    • Galleries
  • Commentary
    • Back
    • Commentary
    • Urgent Matters
    • View From The Top
    • All Things IWCE
    • Legal Matters
  • Resources
    • Back
    • Resources
    • Webinars
    • White Papers
    • Reprints & Reuse
  • IWCE
    • Back
    • IWCE
    • Conference
    • Special Events
    • Exhibitor Listings
    • Premier Partners
    • Floor Plan
    • Exhibiting Information
    • Register for IWCE
  • About Us
    • Back
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Cookies Policy
  • Related Sites
    • Back
    • American City & County
    • IWCE
    • Light Reading
    • IOT World Today
    • Mission Critical Technologies
    • Microwave/RF
    • T&D World
    • TU-Auto
  • In the field
    • Back
    • In the field
    • Broadband Push-to-X
    • Internet of Things
    • Project 25
    • Public-Safety Broadband/FirstNet
    • Virtual/Augmented Reality
    • Land Mobile Radio
    • Long Term Evolution (LTE)
    • Applications
    • Drones/Robots
    • IoT/Smart X
    • Software
    • Subscriber Devices
    • Video
  • Call Center/Command
    • Back
    • Call Center/Command
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • NG911
    • Alerting Systems
    • Analytics
    • Dispatch/Call-taking
    • Incident Command/Situational Awareness
    • Tracking, Monitoring & Control
  • Network Tech
    • Back
    • Network Tech
    • Interoperability
    • LMR 100
    • LMR 200
    • Backhaul
    • Deployables
    • Power
    • Tower & Site
    • Wireless Networks
    • Coverage/Interference
    • Security
    • System Design
    • System Installation
    • System Operation
    • Test & Measurement
  • Operations
    • Back
    • Operations
    • Critical Infrastructure
    • Enterprise
    • Federal Government/Military
    • Public Safety
    • State & Local Government
    • Training
  • Regulations
    • Back
    • Regulations
    • Narrowbanding
    • T-Band
    • Rebanding
    • TV White Spaces
    • None
    • Funding
    • Policy
    • Regional Coordination
    • Standards
  • Organizations
    • Back
    • Organizations
    • AASHTO
    • APCO
    • DHS
    • DMR Association
    • ETA
    • EWA
    • FCC
    • IWCE
    • NASEMSO
    • NATE
    • NXDN Forum
    • NENA
    • NIST/PSCR
    • NPSTC
    • NTIA/FirstNet
    • P25 TIG
    • TETRA + CCA
    • UTC
Urgent Communications
  • NEWSLETTER
  • Home
  • News
  • Multimedia
    • Back
    • Video
    • Podcasts
    • Omdia Crit Comms Circle Podcast
    • Galleries
    • IWCE’s Video Showcase
  • Commentary
    • Back
    • All Things IWCE
    • Urgent Matters
    • View From The Top
    • Legal Matters
  • Resources
    • Back
    • Webinars
    • White Papers
    • Reprints & Reuse
    • UC eZines
    • Sponsored content
  • IWCE
    • Back
    • Conference
    • Why Attend
    • Exhibitor Listing
    • Floor Plan
    • Exhibiting Information
    • Join the Event Mailing List
  • About Us
    • Back
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Cookies Policy
  • Related Sites
    • Back
    • American City & County
    • IWCE
    • Light Reading
    • IOT World Today
    • TU-Auto
  • newsletter
  • In the field
    • Back
    • Internet of Things
    • Broadband Push-to-X
    • Project 25
    • Public-Safety Broadband/FirstNet
    • Virtual/Augmented Reality
    • Land Mobile Radio
    • Long Term Evolution (LTE)
    • Applications
    • Drones/Robots
    • IoT/Smart X
    • Software
    • Subscriber Devices
    • Video
  • Call Center/Command
    • Back
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • NG911
    • Alerting Systems
    • Analytics
    • Dispatch/Call-taking
    • Incident Command/Situational Awareness
    • Tracking, Monitoring & Control
  • Network Tech
    • Back
    • Cybersecurity
    • Interoperability
    • LMR 100
    • LMR 200
    • Backhaul
    • Deployables
    • Power
    • Tower & Site
    • Wireless Networks
    • Coverage/Interference
    • Security
    • System Design
    • System Installation
    • System Operation
    • Test & Measurement
  • Operations
    • Back
    • Critical Infrastructure
    • Enterprise
    • Federal Government/Military
    • Public Safety
    • State & Local Government
    • Training
  • Regulations
    • Back
    • Narrowbanding
    • T-Band
    • Rebanding
    • TV White Spaces
    • None
    • Funding
    • Policy
    • Regional Coordination
    • Standards
  • Organizations
    • Back
    • AASHTO
    • APCO
    • DHS
    • DMR Association
    • ETA
    • EWA
    • FCC
    • IWCE
    • NASEMSO
    • NATE
    • NXDN Forum
    • NENA
    • NIST/PSCR
    • NPSTC
    • NTIA/FirstNet
    • P25 TIG
    • TETRA + CCA
    • UTC
acc.com

Land Mobile Radio


News

Judge orders Hytera to make large royalty payment this month to Motorola Solutions

Judge orders Hytera to make large royalty payment this month to Motorola Solutions

  • Written by Donny Jackson
  • 6th July 2022

Hytera Communications must make a lump-sum royalty payment—estimated to be $45 million—by the end of this month, based on the China-based company’s sales of DMR products that utilize Motorola Solutions trade secrets and copyrighted software during the past three years, according to a federal judge’s order.

U.S. Federal District Court Judge Charles Norgle yesterday also issued rulings that denied Motorola Solutions’ requests for a permanent injunction against Hytera, a financial turnover requirement by Hytera, and a finding that the China-based LMR manufacturer be held in contempt of court. Separately, Norgle’s order—also released yesterday—affirmed the terms associated with Hytera Communications’ scheduled ongoing royalty payments of $80.32 per applicable terminal radio and $378.16 per repeater that would be held for Motorola Solutions in an escrow account until legal appeals are exhausted.

Under terms submitted to Norgle in a joint proposal from Hytera and Motorola Solutions, Hytera typically will pay the royalty fees associated from the sale of relevant DMR products for the previous quarter, with payments due on January 31, April 30, July 31, and October 31 of each year.

However, the first financial outlay is scheduled to be a lump-sum payment reflecting the royalties owed on Hytera sales from July 1, 2019, through June 30, 2022. Hytera is required to inform Motorola of the amount owed by July 21, and the payment is due on July 31.

It is unclear how much Hytera is expected to owe in this initial royalty payment, but legal documents filed during the case have estimated the total would be at least $45 million. Motorola Solutions has the right to have an “internationally recognized accounting firm … examine and audit” to ensure the accuracy of Hytera’s sales figures and royalty calculations, according to Norgle’s order.

Whether Hytera will make this payment also is in doubt. To date, Hytera has made no payments toward the adjusted $543.7 million judgment against the China-based firm from March 2020, when Norgle supported the unanimous findings of a jury at the conclusion of a four-month trial conducted in Chicago. Hytera also has refused to secure a bond associated with the judgment—a fact that Motorola Solutions lawyers have noted repeatedly in filings.

Motorola Solutions attorneys repeatedly have filed briefs claiming that they do not believe Hytera will make its required royalty payments. If Hytera is determined to have any “underpayments” of the royalty fees, the China-based LMR company will have to pay a surcharge penalty that is staggered, based on the percentage of the underpayment, according to Norgle’s order.

For example, if Hytera underpays by 5-10% of the due amount, Hytera would pay an additional surcharge of 10% of the underpayment, the order states. The surcharge percentage increases as the underpayment percentage increase on a staggered basis, with Hytera paying a 100% additional surcharge on any underpayment that exceeds 50%.

Motorola Solutions expressed support for Norgle’s order in a statement provided to IWCE’s Urgent Communications.

“We are pleased Judge Norgle has entered a formal order requiring Hytera to pay Motorola Solutions perpetual royalties of $80.32 per unit for Hytera radios and $378.16 per unit for Hytera repeaters that utilize Motorola Solutions’ stolen trade secrets and copyrighted source code,” according to the Motorola Solutions’ statement.

“This is in addition to the $543.7 million in compensatory and punitive damages Hytera owes Motorola Solutions, underscoring the scope of Hytera’s theft and ongoing illegal use of Motorola Solutions’ intellectual property and innovations.”

Hytera Communications did not respond to a request for comment from IWCE’s Urgent Communications in time to be included in this article.

Separately, Norgle denied multiple requests from Motorola Solutions to take actions against Hytera.

Most notably, Norgle denied Motorola Solutions’ request for the judge to reconsider issuing a permanent injunction against Hytera that would have prevented the China-based LMR firm from selling specific DMR products that use the Motorola trade secrets and copyrighted software.

Norgle denied a similar permanent-injunction request in December 2020, when Norgle determined that the only reason not to issue a permanent injunction was that Hytera already was being punished by being required to pay monetary damages in the case.

“Now, says Motorola, Hytera has made it abundantly clear since the court’s order that it does not intend to pay the judgment against it. Indeed, says, Motorola, Hytera claims it has no ability to pay,” Norgle’s ruling states. “Therefore, given that Motorola allegedly cannot be compensated with money, it has been irreparably harmed, and the court should issue a permanent injunction.”

Norgle’s ruling indicates that a permanent injunction against Hytera may be legally appropriate at this time, but the federal judge does not believe he has the power to make such a ruling, because Motorola Solutions already has cross-appealed his previous permanent-injunction ruling to the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals.

“The court lacks jurisdiction to grant the motion,” Norgle’s ruling states.

“Motorola argued that Hytera’s cited appeal was premature, because the court had yet to finalize the issue of a reasonable royalty, and that the appeal … was dismissed for that very reason. However, a subsequent appeal and cross-appeal were filed last month, after the court determined the amount of the reasonable royalty. The court therefore finds that it lacks jurisdiction to grant the relief Motorola seeks.”

Norgle also denied Motorola Solutions’ motion that would compel Hytera Communications to turnover $168 million that the company has disclosed as its cash assets, as well as find Hytera in contempt of court for failing to begin paying any of the damages it owes in the case.

“While the court has the discretion to order turnover of funds at this time, it declines to exercise that discretion at this time,” Norgle’s ruling states, noting that virtually all key matters have been appealed to the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals.

“The court anticipates that this significant appeal will be ruled on expeditiously by the Seventh Circuit. Accordingly, the court finds that exercising its discretion to order turnover at this point would be premature. As [Motorola Solutions] states, Hytera continues to be a lucrative corporation that generates significant revenues. Nothing in the record hints that Hytera may become insolvent or judgment-proof. Plaintiff’s motion for turnover is denied without prejudice at this time.”

Hytera needs to continue to produce “relevant document” as required during the case, according to Norgle.

“The court reiterates that Hytera much produce information regarding the amount and location of its assets, including non-public information, if disclosure does not subject Hytera to civil and criminal liability,” Norgle’s ruling states. “Failure to do so may result in Hytera being held in contempt.”

In a March 2020 judgment, Norgle affirmed a unanimous jury finding that Hytera should pay $764.6 million for its use of DMR trade secrets and copyrighted software developed by Motorola. Norgle reduced this initial award amount to $543.7 million in January, noting that collecting $220.9 million of the original ruling “would constitute a double recovery.”

But these damages only addressed Hytera sales of certain DMR products—those that used the stolen trade secrets and copyrighted software developed by Motorola—through June 30, 2019. Hytera has continued to sell these “covered products” even after this date, and the royalty payments established by Norgle are designed to compensate Motorola Solutions for Hytera sales of these products beginning on July 1, 2019.

Norgle’s order stipulates that Hytera’s first escrow payment will be due on July 31, when the China-based LMR firm is required to make a lump-sum payment of all royalties for the three-year period from July 1, 2019, to June 30, 2022.

In legal filings, Hytera has indicated that it may be unable to pay, noting that the company’s finances have been strained further by the fact that the U.S. Department of Justice (DoJ) in February indicted the China-based LMR firm of criminal conspiracy to steal DMR trade secrets from Motorola (before the company was renamed Motorola Solutions). This 21-count indictment against Hytera Communications was followed in April by the identification of seven individuals who participated in the alleged criminal conspiracy.

Both the civil and criminal cases against Hytera center around allegations that Hytera developed much of its successful DMR product line using trade secrets and copyrighted software that was stolen from Motorola Solutions about 14 years ago.

During the federal-court trial that began in November 2019, Hytera attorneys acknowledged that three former Motorola (the company had not yet changed its name to Motorola Solutions at the time) employees—Samuel Chia, Y.T. Kok and G.S. Kok—accessed more than 7,000 Motorola documents prior to each of them leaving and joining Hytera shortly in 2008. However, Hytera attorneys described the three engineers as “bad apples” who did not share with anyone else at Hytera that the DMR trade secrets and software were taken from Motorola.

All three of the former Motorola employees that were hired by Hytera invoked the Fifth Amendment when interviewed as part of the civil-suit proceedings. The DoJ indictment notes that there are individual defendants charged in the Hytera criminal conspiracy case, but all of those names were redacted from the publicly available version of the indictment.

 

 

Tags: homepage-featured-4 Critical Infrastructure Enterprise Federal Government/Military Funding Land Mobile Radio News Policy Software Standards State & Local Government Subscriber Devices System Design System Operation Wireless Networks News

Most Recent


  • Research claims driverless tech still too easy to trick
    Autonomous vehicles can be easily manipulated into performing undesirable driving behavior through the placement of ordinary objects on the roadside, according to a study from the University of California, Irvine (UCI). The research team set up a course on the UCLA campus to test the reactions of driverless cars, running the open-source AD systems Apollo […]
  • Coalition expresses urgent need to NG911 funding, wants more than proposed $10 billion
    ANAHEIM—Public Safety NG911 Coalition representatives expressed support for legislation that calls for as much as $10 billion in spectrum-auctions proceeds to be used to fund the transition to next-generation 911 technology, but they want the money to be available soon and believe more than $10 billion is necessary. These statements were made yesterday during a […]
  • APCO releases NG911 guide, quickly clarifies stance on NENA's i3 standard
    ANAHEIM—At its annual trade show, the Association of Public-Safety Communications Officials (APCO) yesterday announced the release of its “Definitive Guide to Next-Generation 911” and, hours later, issued a press release to clarify its position on the i3 standard developed by the National Emergency Number Association (NENA). APCO International Executive Director and CEO Derek Poarch announced […]
  • 10 malicious code packages slither into PyPI registry
    Administrators of the Python Package Index (PyPI) have removed 10 malicious software code packages from the registry after a security vendor informed them about the issue. The incident is the latest in a rapidly growing list of recent instances where threat actors have placed rogue software on widely used software repositories such as PyPI, Node Package […]

2 comments

  1. Avatar Tim Kenelly 8th July 2022 @ 1:15 pm
    Reply

    Donny,

    Is Hytera still listed as a defendant in the DOJ case? Because in the April unsealed indictment Hyteta was not listed as a defendant (unlike the original indictment from February).

    • Avatar Donny Jackson 8th July 2022 @ 3:10 pm
      Reply

      Yes, Hytera Communications is still the primary defendant in the DoJ criminal case (listed as United States of America v. Hytera Communications Corporation, Ltd, et al). The April announcement publicly identified some individuals being charged whose names were redacted from the original indictment in February.

Leave a comment Cancel reply

To leave a comment login with your Urgent Comms account:

Log in with your Urgent Comms account

Or alternatively provide your name, email address below:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Content

  • Hytera, Motorola Solutions refile appeal, cross-appeal in civil case
  • DoJ alleges seven individuals part of Hytera DMR conspiracy against Motorola
  • Federal judge orders Hytera to make substantial DMR royalty payment in July
  • Judge sets royalty fees Hytera must pay Motorola Solutions on certain DMR sales

Commentary


LTE and liability: Why the fire service must move forward with digital incident command

  • 2
6th May 2022

Partnership and collaboration must be the foundation for emergency communications

18th April 2022

FirstNet success means no hypothetical ‘shots’ need to be fired, Swenson says

22nd February 2022
view all

Events


UC Ezines


IWCE 2019 Wrap Up

13th May 2019
view all

Twitter


UrgentComm

Research claims driverless tech still too easy to trick dlvr.it/SWMDts

10th August 2022
UrgentComm

Coalition expresses urgent need to NG911 funding, wants more than proposed $10 billion dlvr.it/SWL5VW

9th August 2022
UrgentComm

APCO releases NG911 guide, quickly clarifies stance on NENA’s i3 standard dlvr.it/SWKcCY

9th August 2022
UrgentComm

10 malicious code packages slither into PyPI registry dlvr.it/SWKHxl

9th August 2022
UrgentComm

Verizon Frontline deploys 1,000 connectivity services for nationwide wildfire response efforts dlvr.it/SWKGpW

9th August 2022
UrgentComm

Newscan: Verizon counts 5.1 million first-responder subs; AT&T has 3.7 million dlvr.it/SW84Gv

6th August 2022
UrgentComm

Taiwan crisis another blow to the supply chain dlvr.it/SW7GSs

5th August 2022
UrgentComm

Motorola Solutions seeks contempt finding, global injunction against Hytera for not paying royalty dlvr.it/SW6Ldm

5th August 2022

Newsletter

Sign up for UrgentComm’s newsletters to receive regular news and information updates about Communications and Technology.

Expert Commentary

Learn from experts about the latest technology in automation, machine-learning, big data and cybersecurity.

Business Media

Find the latest videos and media from the market leaders.

Media Kit and Advertising

Want to reach our digital and print audiences? Learn more here.

DISCOVER MORE FROM INFORMA TECH

  • American City & County
  • IWCE
  • Light Reading
  • IOT World Today
  • Mission Critical Technologies
  • TU-Auto

WORKING WITH US

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Events
  • Careers

FOLLOW Urgent Comms ON SOCIAL

  • Privacy
  • CCPA: “Do Not Sell My Data”
  • Cookies Policy
  • Terms
Copyright © 2022 Informa PLC. Informa PLC is registered in England and Wales with company number 8860726 whose registered and Head office is 5 Howick Place, London, SW1P 1WG.
This website uses cookies, including third party ones, to allow for analysis of how people use our website in order to improve your experience and our services. By continuing to use our website, you agree to the use of such cookies. Click here for more information on our Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy.
X